Deathbird Stories by Harlan Ellison

I hon­est­ly don’t know why this book was in the Top 50 Sci­ence Fic­tion books list. Death­bird Sto­ries by Har­lan Elli­son is a col­lec­tion of short sto­ries that wres­tle with gods and wor­ship­pers, both new and old, and from dif­fer­ent angles.

As is typ­i­cal with Elli­son, none of the char­ac­ters in any of the sto­ries are par­tic­u­lar­ly nice peo­ple, and some of the sto­ries seem to skirt rather close to alle­go­ry or are too didac­tic for my taste[Pret­ty Mag­gie Mon­eyeyes; Paingod] while oth­ers were a bit prophet­ic. Along the Scenic Route is about road rage, for instance. I got the feel­ing that Elli­son would equate gods and demons as the same thing, so his premise in the intro­duc­tion end­ed up con­fus­ing me lat­er one when some of the gods seemed like noth­ing more than indulging inter­nal and whol­ly human desires, instead of more obvi­ous gods.

I’m pret­ty sure Elli­son is an athe­ist, so his crit­i­cal tacks on god­li­ness are strong, but his gods them­selves are so weak as to seem mere­ly human. And at times I think his desire to be irrev­er­ent mere­ly to seem rebel­lious over­pow­ers his writ­ing abil­i­ty. That might have been his point I sup­pose, though it does­n’t do much for me. He throws around quotes from Niet­zsche and oth­er folks, which I guess were prob­a­bly the impe­tus for writ­ing some of the sto­ries. There is a sto­ry about Jesus and Prometheus as lovers, a sto­ry about a land where gods go when they no longer have wor­ship­pers, a Cthu­lu-like sto­ry about mur­der and sac­ri­fice in Man­hat­tan, and a cou­ple oth­ers.

The only one that real­ly sticks out in my mind as a qual­i­ty sto­ry is the last one, The Death­bird. It is prob­a­bly the most pol­y­se­mous sto­ry in the col­lec­tion. The main premise is that his­to­ry is writ­ten by the vic­tors. The Chris­t­ian God is the vic­tor, but Satan and Moth­er Earth are against him, because he is mad. So way in the future, the last man, who was kept safe in Hell [at the core of the earth], is wok­en by Satan, who is a one-eyed shad­ow, and who takes him through the tri­als of the desert and up the metaphor­i­cal moun­tain where the man is test­ed by God. The man with­stands the tests of God, real­izes he is stronger and more pow­er­ful than God [or Satan, who becomes man’s friend and wor­ship­per] and then since Man art God, the man ends the world and [appar­ent­ly] the uni­verse. And every­one is glad. Now, that sounds pret­ty didac­tic, but the sto­ry is writ­ten well enough that you don’t real­ize you’ve learned a new angle of look­ing at things until the end. If sub­ver­sion was what he was aim­ing for, he did it best in that sto­ry.

The rest of the book… meh.

Leave a Reply